How and Why Matter Exists: Is the Electron’s Shape The Key?

The Birth of the Universe and The Puzzle of Asymmetry

In the genesis of our universe, a staggering quantity of protons, neutrons, and electrons formed, accompanied by their antimatter counterparts. As the universe expanded and cooled, these matter and antimatter particles engaged in a cataclysmic dance, annihilating each other and leaving only photons—flashes of light—in their aftermath. This is a fundamental part of the understanding of the Big Bang theory, which posits that at the moment of the universe’s birth, it was filled with a high-energy plasma of particles and antiparticles. The mutual annihilation of these particles created radiation that is still detectable today as the cosmic microwave background.

Yet if the universe was perfectly symmetrical, embodying an equal distribution of matter and antimatter, that annihilation would be the end of the story—and we would not exist. However, an imbalance must have occurred—excess protons, neutrons, and electrons—that went on to form atoms, molecules, stars, planets, galaxies, and eventually, life as we know it. “If the universe had been perfectly symmetrical, then there would be nothing left but light. This is a hugely important moment in history. Suddenly there is stuff in the universe, and the question is, why?” posited NIST/JILA Fellow Eric Cornell. This excess of matter over antimatter, known as baryon asymmetry, is one of the biggest unsolved problems in physics.

Asymmetry Theories and The Importance of Experimental Evidence

Mathematical theories and equations that map out our universe propose symmetry. Over the years, particle theorists have fine-tuned these theories to address the presence of asymmetry. Yet, without concrete evidence, these theories remain purely mathematical, Cornell expounds. Consequently, experimental physicists, including his team at JILA, have been scrutinizing fundamental particles like electrons for signs of asymmetry.

Recently, the JILA team achieved a groundbreaking measurement of electrons, homing in on the source of this asymmetry. Their findings have been shared in Science, a highly respected peer-reviewed journal. Here it is worth noting that experimental physics is a vital complement to theoretical physics, providing the critical empirical data that validate or refute theoretical predictions.

Hunting for Asymmetry: The Role of Electron’s Electric Dipole Moment

One possible location for asymmetry evidence is the electron’s electric dipole moment (eEDM). Electrons possess a negative electric charge, and the eEDM demonstrates how evenly this charge is dispersed between the electron’s poles. An eEDM value above zero would substantiate an asymmetry; the electron would be more oval than round. However, the magnitude of this potential deviation is unknown.

“We need to align our mathematics closer to reality,” Tanya Roussy, a graduate student in Cornell’s research group at JILA, stated. She emphasized that their team’s quest is to discover where this asymmetry could be, facilitating an understanding of its origin. “Electrons are fundamental particles, and their symmetry—or lack thereof—offers insights about the universe’s symmetry.”

Cornell, Roussy, and their collaborative team at NIST and JILA recently set a new benchmark for precision in measuring eEDM, improving previous measurements by a factor of 2.4.

Probing Precision: How Tiny Is the Asymmetry?

To provide perspective on this precision, if an electron were the size of the Earth, the discovered asymmetry—if any—would be smaller than the radius of an atom, as explained by Roussy.

Achieving such remarkable precision is challenging. The researchers resorted to studying molecules of hafnium fluoride. When a strong electric field is applied to these molecules, non-spherical electrons will try to align with the field, causing movement within the molecule. If the electrons were perfectly spherical, they would remain stationary.

The team used an ultraviolet laser to strip electrons from molecules, producing a group of positively charged ions, and captured them. By alternating the electromagnetic field around this “trap,” the molecules were forced to either align or not align with the field. Subsequently, lasers were used to measure the energy levels of these two groups. A disparity in energy levels between the groups would suggest the electrons were asymmetrical.

Despite the painstaking precision and complexity of the experiment, the group’s measurements revealed that the electrons did not shift energy levels. This suggests that, as far as our current capability to measure, electrons appear to be round.

The Quest Continues: Unraveling the Mystery of Universal Asymmetry

Cornell acknowledges there’s no certainty that a nonzero measurement of eEDM will be found. However, this level of precision from a lab-scale experiment represents a milestone. It proves that large-scale particle accelerators are not the only means of probing these fundamental questions about the universe. It opens a myriad of avenues for exploration. While the team didn’t uncover asymmetry, its findings will assist the field in further seeking answers to the asymmetry of the early universe.

“We found that up to our measurement, the electron is symmetric. If we would have found a nonzero eEDM, it would be a significant finding,” Roussy stated. “The best approach is to have global teams of scientists exploring different avenues. As long as we all continue seeking the truth, eventually, someone will find it.”

Tracing the Path of the Universe: The Matter-Antimatter Imbalance

The universe’s current state raises a puzzling question that has been the center of various scientific studies—why is there more matter than antimatter? Our current understanding of physics suggests that matter and antimatter should have been created in equal amounts during the Big Bang, yet our universe is overwhelmingly composed of matter. The imbalance between matter and antimatter is known as the matter-antimatter asymmetry, a fundamental mystery that physics has yet to fully unravel.

One of the leading theories postulates that some type of asymmetry must have tipped the scales in favor of matter during the early stages of the universe. This asymmetry could be hiding in the behavior of fundamental particles. Current standard models of particle physics don’t account for a large enough asymmetry to explain the universe’s matter dominance, hence the necessity for the exploration of other possibilities, such as investigating the shape of electrons.

The recent study led by Cornell and Roussy provides a powerful tool in this quest, providing insights into the universe’s past and laying the groundwork for future research. Yet, the ultimate resolution of the matter-antimatter asymmetry puzzle remains one of the most significant challenges in modern physics.

The Electric Dipole Moment: A Symmetry-Breaking Indicator

Understanding the shape of an electron could offer profound insights into the mysteries of the universe, and the Electric Dipole Moment (eEDM) is key in this endeavor. The eEDM is a measure of the distribution of an electron’s charge. A nonzero eEDM would mean that the electron is not perfectly round but instead slightly egg-shaped, indicating a possible source of the symmetry violation that could account for the matter-antimatter imbalance in the universe.

However, measuring an electron’s eEDM with precision is an incredibly challenging task. The advanced technique developed by Cornell, Roussy, and their team, involving the use of an ultraviolet laser, electromagnetic fields, and hafnium fluoride molecules, allows for measurements with unparalleled accuracy. Though the search for a nonzero eEDM continues, the advancements in measurement techniques are notable achievements in themselves.

Beyond the Large Hadron Collider: The Power of Tabletop Experiments

Cornell’s team has demonstrated that insights into the universe’s fundamental properties can be gleaned not only from multi-billion dollar particle accelerators like the Large Hadron Collider but also from tabletop experiments. Their study challenges the notion that the exploration of fundamental physics necessitates monumental machines and complex infrastructure.

This finding could democratize the field, allowing research groups with fewer resources to make significant contributions. It encourages creativity and innovative thinking in devising new ways to probe the mysteries of the universe. This democratization could potentially speed up discoveries, as more and more research groups around the world can participate in seeking answers to the universe’s biggest questions.

Collaboration in Physics: The Global Search for Truth

The search for the origins of the universe’s matter-antimatter asymmetry is a global effort. The collaboration between NIST and JILA highlights the value of inter-institutional partnerships in advancing scientific understanding.

Teams of scientists worldwide are working towards the same goal: to find the truth about our universe. They test different theories, share findings, and build upon each other’s work. This global collaboration is a powerful tool in science and an embodiment of the scientific method: global teams collectively testing, refining, and sometimes discarding theories in pursuit of truth.

Peering into the Future: The Unresolved Mysteries of Physics

Despite the advances made by the team, the mystery of the universe’s asymmetry remains unresolved. Their measurements have shown that as far as we can currently measure, electrons are round. However, this doesn’t preclude the possibility that with even more precise measurements or innovative approaches, a nonzero eEDM could be found.

This study highlights that even in an era where we can manipulate atoms and peer into the distant reaches of the universe, there are still many fundamental questions about the universe that remain unanswered. The exploration of these questions promises to yield a deeper understanding of our universe, further elucidating the enigmatic laws that govern the cosmos. The pursuit of answers to these questions drives the field of physics forward, demonstrating the endless curiosity of the human spirit.

The Impact of Asymmetry Research on Humanity and the Scientific Community

The groundbreaking research conducted by the NIST/JILA team, though centered on complex and seemingly distant principles of physics, holds significant implications for both scientific progress and humanity as a whole.

Firstly, the team’s work contributes to advancing our fundamental understanding of the universe. The question of why the universe contains more matter than antimatter is one of the most profound unanswered questions in cosmology. By investigating the possibility of asymmetry in the properties of electrons, researchers are laying the groundwork for new theories that could potentially resolve this cosmic mystery. The work may represent a critical step towards a more complete and unified understanding of the universe’s fundamental laws, potentially leading to a new era of physics.

Secondly, the innovative experimental techniques developed in this research could inspire new technological advancements. The precise measurement techniques used in the investigation of electron’s shape might find applications in areas beyond fundamental physics. Precise measurements at the quantum level are essential in the emerging field of quantum computing, and the techniques developed by the NIST/JILA team could potentially contribute to advancements in this field.

Thirdly, demonstrating that major advancements in fundamental physics research can be achieved through tabletop experiments, as opposed to only through large, expensive particle accelerators, can facilitate a broader diversity of research endeavors. This research democratizes the field, providing opportunities for institutions with varying resources to contribute meaningfully to our understanding of the universe. This can also foster increased scientific collaboration, with teams worldwide combining their unique perspectives and resources to explore these fundamental questions.

Fourthly, the research underscores the ongoing quest to unravel the mysteries of the universe, which is a captivating story that can inspire public interest in science. When the public is engaged in scientific dialogues, this can lead to increased support for scientific research, improved science education, and a more scientifically literate populace. These factors are crucial for addressing many of the complex challenges faced by humanity in the 21st century.

Lastly, the pursuit of answers to these fundamental questions in physics often leads to unexpected discoveries. As we probe deeper into the quantum realm and reach new levels of experimental precision, who knows what surprising phenomena we might uncover? This venture into the unknown is what pushes science forward, and the potential for unexpected discoveries is perhaps one of the most exciting implications of the NIST/JILA team’s research.

The exploration of the asymmetry of the universe is more than a purely academic endeavor; it holds potential impacts for technological innovation, scientific collaboration, public engagement with science, and the future of discovery.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the matter-antimatter imbalance?The matter-antimatter imbalance refers to the observation that there is far more matter than antimatter in the universe. This contradicts the assumption that equal amounts of matter and antimatter were created during the Big Bang. This discrepancy is one of the greatest unsolved mysteries in physics.
2. What is an electron’s electric dipole moment (eEDM)?An electron’s electric dipole moment (eEDM) is a measure of the distribution of an electron’s electric charge. An eEDM value above zero would suggest that the electron’s charge is not perfectly symmetrical and that the electron’s shape is more like an egg than a perfect sphere. This could hint at the presence of new physics beyond the Standard Model.
3. Why is the roundness of electrons significant?The roundness of electrons is significant because it could hold clues to the matter-antimatter imbalance in the universe. If electrons are found to be perfectly round, it supports the symmetry suggested by the Standard Model of particle physics. However, if electrons are found to be slightly asymmetrical, it could provide evidence for new physical theories that could explain why the universe contains more matter than antimatter.
4. How did the NIST/JILA team measure the roundness of electrons?The NIST/JILA team conducted an experiment using hafnium fluoride molecules, an electric field, and an ultraviolet laser to measure the roundness of electrons. Their findings indicate that, as best as we can currently measure, electrons appear to be round.
5. What are the implications of this research?This research contributes to our understanding of the universe’s fundamental laws and can inspire new technological advancements, such as in quantum computing. It also suggests that major advancements in fundamental physics research can be achieved through tabletop experiments, thus democratizing the field and fostering global scientific collaboration. Additionally, the research can inspire public interest in science and lead to unexpected discoveries.
6. What are tabletop experiments?Tabletop experiments are scientific experiments that do not require large-scale, expensive equipment like particle accelerators. They can be performed on a laboratory bench, or “tabletop,” using relatively small and less expensive equipment. This makes the experiments more accessible to a larger number of research institutions.
7. What is the significance of the improved precision in the NIST/JILA team’s measurements?The improved precision in the NIST/JILA team’s measurements is significant as it narrows down the possible range for the eEDM value and thus the possible deviation from the roundness of the electron. This greater precision also helps improve the accuracy of our understanding of the universe’s fundamental laws and may also contribute to advancements in fields that require precise measurements at the quantum level, such as quantum computing.

Conclusion: The Unending Quest for Knowledge

The research conducted by the NIST/JILA team demonstrates a pivotal step forward in our pursuit of comprehending the cosmos. By examining the potential asymmetry in electrons, the team provides key insights into the deep-seated mystery of why matter predominates over antimatter in the universe.

Though their results, for now, suggest that the electron’s shape is round within the precision of their measurements, the investigation itself is a testament to the power of innovative scientific techniques. The team’s ability to measure the properties of electrons with such precision using a tabletop setup broadens the horizon for many other research institutions, suggesting that one does not need a massive particle accelerator to make meaningful contributions to fundamental physics.

Moreover, this research exemplifies the collaborative spirit of the scientific community. The concerted efforts of researchers around the world, each conducting experiments, testing theories, and sharing results, underline the dynamic and collective nature of scientific progress. This global pursuit of knowledge is continually moving us closer to the truth about our universe’s mysteries.

Importantly, the team’s research also opens doors for technological innovation. The methodologies employed and advancements made in measurement precision could catalyze progress in areas such as quantum computing. The intertwined nature of fundamental research and technological development is a testament to the multifaceted impact of scientific inquiry.

Finally, the research underscores the fact that our quest to understand the universe is far from over. As we probe deeper into the quantum realm and reach new levels of experimental precision, we continually discover more questions to be answered. Yet, each question brings us closer to a holistic understanding of the cosmos and elucidates the intriguingly complex nature of our universe. As we move forward in this scientific journey, the universe’s mysteries continue to captivate us, reminding us of the beauty and vastness of the cosmos we inhabit.

Read Original Article: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adg4084

Deep Dive

1. “Observation of Antiprotons.” Chamberlain, O., Segre, E., Wiegand, C., & Ypsilantis, T. (1955). Physical Review.
2. “Antimatter in the universe.” Steigman, G. (2008). Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics.
3. “The mystery of the matter asymmetry.” Canetti, L., Drewes, M., & Shaposhnikov, M. (2012). Annalen der Physik.
4. “Are we at the dawn of post–standard model era?—an introduction to the problem of the matter–antimatter asymmetry of the universe.” Devi, M. M., Gautam, R., & Mohanta, R. (2019). European Physical Journal Plus.
5. “Searching for new physics: CP violation and the matter-antimatter asymmetry.” Imbeault, R. (2007). Physics in Canada.
6. “CP violation and baryogenesis.” Trodden, M. (1999). Review of Modern Physics.
7. “Leptogenesis from quantum interference in a thermal bath.” Huet, P., & Sather, E. (1995). Physical Review D.
8. “Symmetries and Asymmetries in the Universe.” Jaffe, R. (2012). Physics Today.
9. “Upper bound for the electric dipole moment of the electron.” Hudson, J. J., et al. (2011). Nature.
10. “Improved measurement of the shape of the electron.” A. C. Vutha et al. (2020). Nature.